I have had similar trials getting the rear hatch to open. I think I have finally gotten the trick to the opening as others have stated. There certainly is a learning curve to such a simple sounding item. Last night the hatch actually would not lock closed despite multiple tries. Took to dealer today. They have it overnight to see why it will not lock down. The light stays on saying the hatch is open and it rattles when driving. I will let you know what is happening when I find out, hopefully tomorrow.