Thanks for all the responses! (and the pointers to some entertaining threads) I had been a little concerned after reading a review by someone who took one down from Mt. Baldy (not sure which route) and didn't like it. But it sounds like it's pretty well behaved in the mountains. As far as other options-- I eliminated the Prius V pretty fast. It has more cargo space, but less power, and felt like it was laboring to go over a little hill on the test drive with just me and the sales guy in it. When I looked it up, it's about 2 seconds slower 0-60 than my old Saturn SW2 that I'm looking to replace. I also ended up with a regular Prius last week as a rental for a work trip and really didn't like it. Mostly what I'm looking for is small wagon with decent gas mileage and enough power to haul around full, and with bikes on top. The points in favor of the C-max are that it's got great mileage and a lot of power, and it's US made. The subaru has ok mileage and AWD (I'd take advantage of it, but it's not critical), it feels and handles just like the old SW2, and it's a bit less expensive (even pretty far out-- the insurance on the Cmax makes up for a lot of the fuel savings).