In 2008, I looked hard at a 2009 Prius and 2009 Jetta TDI and bought the Jetta. In 2012, I looked hard at a Prius again and bought the C-Max for virtually all the reasons stated above. As I see it, the only two things the Prius has over most cars is fuel economy and reliability. In most other attributes like perfomance, refinements, comfort, handling and so forth, the Prius is woefully lacking. Hopefully, the C-Max will match or surpass the reliability of the Prius. Time will tell. With respect to fuel economy, I was aware prior to buying my C-Max that the fuel economy is likely not going to be as good as a Prius. But, the likely difference in fuel savings with the Prius simply didn't outweigh the other benefits of the C-Max.